I agree that the virus definitions updates should work as they did before and that they stopped working rather suddenly. For me this happened this past November, for you it seems to have happened only very recently. I disagree that this is an isolated problem affecting only a few users… the forum is rife with people reporting the very same or similar issues across various versions of the software and for many of them it started a long time ago.
Re: being “up to date:” My system (XP sp3, Comodo AV Version 5.12.256249.2599) seems to be the same as yours. Also, like yours, when I click Comodo’s “check for (new software) updates” button it replies that my system is current and up to date. Apparently that is kind of true, for Windows XP systems using version 5.12+. Quite some time ago, Comodo released a whole new version (v. 6) that was created mainly for users of newer Windows operating systems (Vista, then Windows 7, then Windows 8 and now 8.1). I remember reading (somewhere in these forums… can’t remember where, and can’t find it now) that the changes made in version 6 and beyond were not particularly relevant for XP systems so it was optional to switch to the new version. Also, in this very thread, one of the experienced volunteers mentioned that since Comodo released version 6 there have been no new program updates for versions 5+ since Comodo AV Version 5.12.256249.2599. So – I am guessing here – the reports we get when we hit the “update” button are relevant only for version 5; i.e., it’s as up to date as version 5 will ever get and there apparently is no “automatic” update to version 6 and beyond using that method, at least not for XP systems. Meanwhile, as I recall, it also was stated that subsequent virus definitions updates would continue to be supported and work for version 5 even as the older software was no longer otherwise being supported.
I suppose all of us XP/v.5+ users could uninstall and wipe out all the traces of version 5 then reinstall the very latest Comodo CIS, but it is my understanding that this doesn’t add any utility or safety for XP that we don’t already have. Perhaps one of the forum heavyweights could elucidate further on this point?
In re: whether my (or your) system has been compromised by some outside forces, that does not appear to be the case, at least for mine. I have tested and retested my system numerous times using most of the more reputable tools – from Spybot to Kaspersky to Malawarebytes and several others – and it always comes up clean. I also log and monitor any outside internet traffic to my network (and each machine on it) and have not found any evidence of unauthorized incursions from incoming or outgoing IP traffic. Short of worrying about the NSA monitoring my every keystroke, the only glitch on my system seems to be this occasional inability to update virus definitions until cmdagent.exe is stopped and restarted.
On this last point, if rebooting does not work for you then my little “shortcut” workaround surely should not work either, which is too bad as I thought I was onto something that could help many/most users who are experiencing the definitions update failures. Obviously, cmdagent.exe is stopped and restarted when you reboot, so if that doesn’t work for you then merely doing it manually “on the fly” will not likely have any effect either, although I look forward to hearing about your results with it to confirm that point. If/when that fails, it would appear that your problem with definitions updates, while similar in to mine in that it hangs on the “finalizing” portion of the update, has a different cause than mine and I’m interested in hearing more as you learn more about it. Thanks.
Cheers,
Eddy