This note is specifically aimed at Melih.
We have corresponded before (You sorted out the GESWALL issue for me in your firewall) You also suggested that I do not sit back but get involved. So here goes
I migrated to Comodo from Look n Stop because Comodo is going places its getting a lot of good press (and some not so good)
I am relatively non technical so when I read some of the things in your forum my eyes glaze over with incomprehension. I used Look n Stop because it was relatively simple it had inbuilt rulesets and if you wanted to be really belt & braces you used the Phantom ruleset. Then LnS started to fail these Shields Up type tests as they have evolved in complexity. In short LnS is not keeping up with the development of threats.
Your product is more complex and on many websites and forums gets great acclaim BUT with the caveat, not for beginners.
I do not know your business model or what segments of the market you are aiming for. But it does seem that you are missing out on a huge chunk at the beginner and “emerging knowledge” end of the market.
There is no such thing as a free lunch, somewhere in your business model there has to be a commercial pay back. Which implies volume. In this context there are likely to be more beginners and modestly technical individuals than your relative experts found in the Comodo forums.
So how do you square the circle with a product that currently is a “dabblers dream” complex & technical AND RESOURCE HUNGRY to one that meets the beginners market and modestly knowledgable AND light on resources and meets your commercial requirements.
Why not produce a lite version of Comodo PF one that only installs effectively in Learning Mode. (Thats all I use because I am not confident enough. or knowledgeable to use the other features)
The trade off has to be a dramatic reduction in resources (Less than the 16 mb that you are currently aiming for). Think of of the marketing logic/hype. Best product, absolutely simple, for beginners. Just install and run. Very low on resources.
If thats not possible because you only want to deal with one piece of software, then why not a default install of Learning mode only, with a corresponding dramatic drop in resource useage. With other sections loadable as “add ins” if the client wants more flexibility or user defined approach. But with increased resorce useage as the pay off.
The current danger is that you engineer yourself into a corner of a market just to meet the needs of technophobes.
I am happy for you to tell me to shut up and that I do not know your market. But I thought marketing was a discipline applied with common sense.
Hope this has raised a thought or two.
Terry
ps I am not yet convinced that Comodo is for me because I am not sure I can get the best protection just using Learning mode. There doesn’t seem to be the impetus for someone to come along (either comodo or a forum user) to provide “belt & bracing” with a ready made enhanced ruleset