Reverting to allow all on logoff or login

I’ve had the firewall installed for a day or so on xp pro (sp2). I’m running ver. 2.4.18.184. It seems that it reverts from custom to allow all every time I’m logging out or in. I’ve seen a couple posts about this happening due to accidentally scrolling the indicator but there’s no way I’m doing this every time I log in or out.

Any ideas?