Kudos to CIS for a great security suite

Hi:
I just finished extensive testing of many security programs including comodo internet security 5.10 and am very impressed with it. Here is my result

I used malware links and malware packs curtsey of malc0de.com.
My test system:
Windows 7 ultimate 32bit using firefox as a defult browser

My scoring was calculated from adding the “proactive” score and “on-deman” score and divided by 2 to get an average score. So this score shows what suite is the bests in overall protection and detection. Rank starts with highest to lowest.

  1. Comodo Internet Security 5.10 (HIGHEST): 85%
  2. Emsisoft antimalware: 82%
  3. Trendmicro Titanium Internet security: 80%
  4. Norton Antivirus: 77%
  5. Panda cloud free: 77%
  6. AVAST ANtivirus free: 77%
  7. Kaspersky Pure: 75%
  8. Bullguard Internet security: 75%
  9. Ad-aware free: 75%
  10. Avira Antivir free: 75%
  11. Vipre Internet security: 75%
  12. Crystal Shield Antivirus free: 72%
  13. Malwarebyte Antimalware Pro: 70%
  14. AVG antivirus free: 67%
  15. PC-Tool Free antivirus: 67%
  16. Kingsoft Antivirus 2012: 67%
  17. Total Defense: 65%
  18. Kingsoft Pc Doctor plus antimalware: 60%
  19. Twister Antivirus: 55%
  20. Microsoft Security Essentials: 55%
  21. Webroot Secure anywhere antivirus: 55%
  22. Forticlient Lite: 55%
  23. Bitdefender Antivirus plus: 52%
  24. Spyware Terminator free: 50%
  25. F-Secure Internet security: 50%
  26. Immunet Free: 47%
  27. Windows Defender: 30%
  28. Anvi Smart Defender Free: 27%
  29. Superantispyware pro: 15%
  30. Rising Free Antivirus: 5%

Proactive protection (Blocking of malwares from running or installing):

  1. Emsisoft Antimalware: 100%
  2. Comodo Internet Security 5.10: 100%
  3. Trendmicro Titanium Internet security: 100%
  4. Panda Cloud free: 100%
  5. Norton Antivirus: 100%
  6. Kaspersky Pure: 100%
  7. Spyware Terminator free: 100%
  8. Bullguard Internet Security: 90%
  9. F-Secure Internet security: 90%
  10. AVAST Antivirus free: 90%
  11. AVG Antivirus free: 80%
  12. Ad-aware free: 80%
  13. Crystal Shield Antivirus 2012: 80%
  14. Pc-Tool Antivirus free: 80%
  15. Vipre Internet security: 70%
  16. Microsoft Security Essentials: 70%
  17. Malwarebyte Antimalware pro: 70%
  18. Kingsoft Antivirus 2012: 70%
  19. Twister ANtivirus: 70%
  20. Avira Antivir free: 70%
  21. Immunet Free: 60%
  22. Total Defense: 60%
  23. Kingsoft Pc doctor plus Antimalware: 50%
  24. Bitdefender Antivirus Plus: 50%
  25. Anvi Smart defender free: 50%
  26. Forticlient Lite: 40%
  27. Windows defender: 40%
  28. Webroot Secure Anywhere Antivirus: 40%
  29. Superantispyware pro: 30%
  30. Rising Free antivirus: 10%

Online Website blocking (Blocked links from downloading)

  1. Emsisoft Antimalware; Panda cloud free (Highest) (100%)
  2. Comodo Internet security 5.10; Ad-aware free; AVG antivirus free; Bullguard Internet security; Crystal Shield Antivirus; Trendmicro Titanium Internet security (80%)
  3. Microsoft Security Essentials; AVAST antivirus free; Pc-Tool Antivirus free; Vipre Internet security (70%)
  4. Norton Antivirus; Immunet free; Total Defender (60%)
  5. Kingsoft Pc Doctor plus Antimalware; Kingsoft Antivirus 2012; Malwarebyte Antimalware pro; Bitdefender Antivirus plus; Kaspersky Pure; Twister antivirus (50%)
  6. Forticlient lite; F-secure Internet security; Windows Defender; Avira Antivir free (40%)
  7. Webroot Secure Anywhere Antivirus (30%)
  8. Superantispyware pro (20%)
  9. Spyware Terminator free; Rising free antivirus; Anvi smart defender free (No blocking) (0%)

On-demand Blocking (Blocking malware on the desktop from running)

  1. Comodo internet security 5.10; Panda cloud antivirus free; Emsisoft Antimalware; Spyware Terminator free; Norton Antivirus; Kaspersky Pure; Trendmicro titanium Internet security (100%)
  2. F-secure Internet security (83%)
  3. AVAST Antivirus free (66%)
  4. Bullguard Internet security; Avira Antivir free; Anvi smart security free (50%)
  5. Kingsoft Antivirus 2012; Malwarebyte Antimalware pro; Twister Antivirus (40%)
  6. Pc-tool antivirus free (33%)
  7. Webroot secure anywhere antivirus (14%)
  8. Superantispyware pro (12%)
  9. Rising free antivirus (10%)
  10. Kingsoft Pc doctor plus Antimalware; Microsoft security essential; Ad-aware free; Forticlient lite; Bitdefender Antivirus plus; Vipre internet security; Windows Defender; Crystal Shield Antivirus; Immunet free; Total defender (0%)

Looks great. Can these results be repeated with additional sets?

Hi:
here are more.

On-demand scanning of a pack of malwares:

  1. Hitman pro: 85%
  2. Avira Antivir free: 80%
  3. Comodo Internet security 5.10; Malwarebyte Antimalware free; Kingsoft Pc Doctor plus antimalware; Webroot secure anywhere antivirus; Ad-aware free; Forticlient Lite: 70%
  4. Emsisoft Antimalware free; Kingsoft Antivirus 2012; Unthreat free antivirus; Crystal Shield Antvirus 2012: 65%
  5. Trendmicro Titanium Internet security; Iobit advanced systemcare plus antivirus; Bullguard Internet security: 60%
  6. AVAST free antivirus; AVG free antivirus; Bitdefender antivirus plus; Pc-tool free antivirus; Norton antivirus; Panda cloud antivirus pro: 55%
  7. Kaspersky pure: 50%
  8. Microsoft security essential; Twister antivirus: 40%
  9. Immunet free; 35%
  10. Windows Defender: 20%
  11. Anvi smart defender: 5%
  12. Superantispyware free: 1.5%
  13. Spyware Terminator free; Iobit malware fighter free: 0%

Hi: Ever since I got setup my VM system I have been testing extensively various products and sure the tests can be repeated.

I forgot to mention that I tweaked with highest setting each security software and in-case of CIS 5.10 I used proactive setting with highest detection and used “Untrust” mode.

Looks very solid. Great results. Thanks for the sharing. Default deny is the only way into the future. ;D :-TU :viva:

:-TU

:-TU CIS is impressive and beta of CIS 6 running very well without a problem.

Thank you for your tests! :-TU

thank you :-TU

Hi:

I did a separate test on just comodo antivirus (no firewall). Used highest settings and features like defense+ and sandbox used. System win 7 ultimate 32bit and firefox and used malcode for malwares.

Result:
60% of links were blocked or detected and removed (by AV & cloud detection).
75% of malwares were stopped from running or installing from the desktop( By defense + sandbox & cloud detection)
Final score: 90%

Hitman pro scanning result: no infection
Malwarebyte scanning result: no infection
Emsisoft scanning result: no infection
Superantispyware scanning result: 1 adware deteced

I presume SAS was FP.
;D

thanks for the time you spent testing those products ! the results validate the great comodo team work !

thank you for your time.

Just saw now. No ESET? Why? ???