1. What actually happened or you saw:
Many traditional AV programs out there are doing quite a “weak job” when it comes to widely spread “adware”. Some companies seem to still regard Adware as more or less “harmless”. So many of us still have to depend on free “special tools” (like AdwCleaner, JRT etc.) to get rid of many unwanted, supposedly (but no more, in their majority) “low-level” nasties.
2. What you wanted to happen or see:
Comodo should integrate a capable, thorough adware scanning / removal tool into CAV / CIS, where the user would at least be able to DECIDE for himself which “Adwares” he might eventually keep (if really so 88)) on his system and which “Adwares” he wants to be erased from it.
3. Why you think it is desirable:
Nowadays there’s a whole bunch of so-called “Adware” being spread that’s often capable of quite more than just “displaying ads” from within a program’s interface (where I’d oftenly rather call such a program “nagware”, i. e. if the “ads” are somewhat related to the company itself (other products, full paid versions etc.). Whilst installing “nagware” should obviously remain a “free option” to any user that I certainly don’t want to “touch” here, many “real adware nasties” nowadays are not really necessary for a program to fully function. Many of them are being installed inside their own folders, leaving their own registry keys, highjacking certain browsers, adding toolbars and the like, downloading further (!) 3rd (!) party nasties (which indeed makes some of them quite comparable to trojans!), don’t offer full uninstall routines etc.
So why do I regard this “desirable”?
Just an example (“fictitious” Comodo forums dialogue I just “made up” from (not so few) real life experiences):
[i]user1: Hi, I’m using CIS* and I’ve got some weird problems (including connection slowdowns, unresponsive system, strange site redirections, nagging popups etc.) obviously related to having “unintentiously” or “by mistake” (i. e. “good belief” ;)) installed an adware I’ve not yet been able to remove using AVthis, AVthat and AVwhatnot. Can you help me please?
user2: Hi, please read here: http://x, http://xx, http://xxx, and you could also try scanning with ToolA, ToolB, ToolC or ToolD, hope this helps.[/i]
Well, such dialogues DO happen. And that’s why I think the above wish is “desirable”. So now you know.
- Shouldn’t have happened with CIS users, of course. Yet it does happen, of course.
4. Any other information:
CAV / CIS should have an option to explicitely and thorougly scan for ANY adware (active or inactive) installed on our beloved machines.
There should, as well, be an option to “untick” any adware a user might eventually (even if rather unlikely) want to keep. (> Similar to the “interactive” list provided by BrightFort’s SpywareBlaster, just for an example).
But what I’d really like to see the most with CIS / CAV: Adware detection / removal capabilities that AT LEAST can finally compete with certain great little “dedicated” free tools like AdwCleaner.
Yes, “THEY can”… so I guess Comodo should be able to at least “compete” with “THEM” (in a friendly way), right? :a0
I sincerely DO hope the answer won’t be: “No, WE can’t.”
And, well, maybe linking the scan results to an online database (but I guess that’d be too much of a demand?) with further information given on any specific adware (“able to install nasties A, B, C, D etc.”) would also be of help and thus quite a desirable thing? (Just a thought, certainly not the most necessary “aspect” of my wish.)
Thanks for reading.
Kind regards, REBOL.