Matousec Firewall Test Results - 2008

[Guest]

[pitzelberger]

comodo is back to the top

http://www.matousec.com/projects/firewall-challenge/results.php

[giraffe]

Thanks for the link.

Looks v. good, apart from the 1 incident that caused damage.

[salmonela]

Aha, now I know why is "\Device\NamedPipe\atsvc" here...

[Commodus]

Yappy !!! Comodo won !   

 

[Matty_R]

 

[ganda]

Comodo Firewall Pro 3.0.19.318FREE                         98%
Online Armor Personal Firewall 2.1.0.112 FreeFREE    94%
ProSecurity 1.43                                                 93%
Outpost Firewall Pro 2008 6.0.2302.264.0490            91%
ZoneAlarm Pro 7.0.462.000                                   74%
Privatefirewall 6.0.11.30                                        65%
Sunbelt Personal Firewall 4.5.916                            18%
ESET Smart Security 3.0.621.0                                     5%


errr, not to spoil the happiness here, does anyone know about the "2%"  why not 100% ?

[Timo Schmidt]

Read the full report (click on the adobe-icon on the right side of the % results)^^

[ganda]

thx Timo Schmidt 
it failed BSODhook SSDT & Kill5 . should i be worry about this 2%
                                     

[salmonela]

thx Timo Schmidt 
it failed BSODhook SSDT & Kill5 . should i be worry about this 2%
                                     

It can be "killed" and can be unstable, "Killing" doesn't worry me to much but "instability" can be problem for "production" machine.

[bey]

It can be "killed" and can be unstable, "Killing" doesn't worry me to much but "instability" can be problem for "production" machine.

Well it did only fail on one of the hooks and it scored best in that test. 

Of course 100% would be better however it is really a huge accomplishment by the devs, so congrats to them! 

[salmonela]

Well it did only fail on one of the hooks and it scored best in that test. 

Of course 100% would be better however it is really a huge accomplishment by the devs, so congrats to them! 

"NtCreatePort vulnerability" has been fixed in 2.xx series but reintroduced again in v.3, it is clearly step backward...
But of course Comodo is no1 and best solution of that type for use, CONGRATULATION

[Ragwing]

Well, I got to say that I'm not surprised that version 3 has reclaimed the top of the mountain!
Good job Comodo! Remember that it isn't just the developers that help making CFP a good software, it's also the users that help Comodo by finding bugs and suggesting new features!

Cheers,
Ragwing

[Commodus]

Remember that it isn't just the developers that help making CFP a good software, it's also the users that help Comodo by finding bugs and suggesting new features!

I like this part very much. It's great to be a small part of Comodo team. Help them to help us 

Great job. Congratulations 

[Melih]

Well, I got to say that I'm not surprised that version 3 has reclaimed the top of the mountain!
Good job Comodo! Remember that it isn't just the developers that help making CFP a good software, it's also the users that help Comodo by finding bugs and suggesting new features!

Cheers,
Ragwing

This is very true indeed!

Credit goes to Everyone from Developers to our Users! This is the first Collabrative Security Effort for Desktops ever seen and it works!!!
 
Melih

[wolfmei]

Comodo V3 the best firewall i ever seen..

[Tags:]